Abstracts
Résumé
Un ensemble des défis rend éminemment critique le rôle des écoles de gestion dans la société. Cet essai adopte une perspective critique visant à mettre en évidence, soutenir et légitimer la capacité des acteurs académiques à se réapproprier, tout en les renouvelant, leur identité professionnelle et leur métier, dans une visée émancipatrice. Cela s’exprime dans les contenus, les formes et les modalités de production de l’enseignement et de la recherche, en lien avec un ensemble élargi d’acteurs au sein et autour de l’institution académique. Trois axes permettent de repenser les écoles de gestion et leurs activités : la temporalité, la spatialité et la dialectique domination/émancipation.
Mots-clés :
- Écoles de gestion,
- approches critiques du management,
- résistance,
- temporalité,
- spatialité,
- dialectique domination/émancipation
Abstract
A set of challenges makes the role of business schools in society eminently critical. This essay adopts a critical perspective aimed at highlighting, supporting and legitimizing the capacity of academic actors to reappropriate, while renewing, their professional identity and their “craft”, with an emancipatory aim. This is expressed in the content, forms and methods of production of teaching and research, in connection with a wider range of actors within and around the academic institution. Three axes allow us to rethink business schools and their activities: temporality, spatiality and the domination/emancipation dialectic.
Keywords:
- Business schools,
- critical management studies,
- resistance,
- temporality,
- spatiality,
- domination/emancipation dialectic
Resumen
Un conjunto de retos hace que el papel de las escuelas de negocios en la sociedad sea eminentemente crítico. Este ensayo adopta una perspectiva crítica destinada a destacar, apoyar y legitimar la capacidad de los actores académicos para reapropiarse, al tiempo que renuevan, su identidad profesional y su profesión, con un objetivo emancipador. Esto se expresa en los contenidos, las formas y los métodos de producción de la enseñanza y la investigación, en conexión con una gama más amplia de actores dentro y alrededor de la institución académica. Tres ejes permiten repensar las escuelas de negocios y sus actividades: la temporalidad, la espacialidad y la dialéctica dominación/emancipación.
Palabras clave:
- Escuelas de gestión,
- enfoques críticos de la gestión,
- resistencia,
- temporalidad,
- espacialidad,
- dialéctica de la dominación/emancipación
Appendices
Bibliographie
- Abdallah, C., Dar, S., Kalemba, J., McCluney, C.L., Mir A. (2021). Anti-Blackness in management and organization studies : Challenging racial capitalism in knowledge production and organizational practices (special issue call for papers). Organization.
- Adler, P. (2016). Our teaching mission, Academy of Management Review, 41(2), 185-195.
- Alajoutsijarvi, K., K. Juusola et M. Siltaoja (2015). The Legitimacy Paradox of Business Schools : Losing by Gaining ?, Academy of Management Learning and Education, 14(2), 277-291.
- Alcadipani, R. (2017). Reclaiming Sociological Reduction : Analysing the Circulation of Management Education in the Periphery, Management Learning, 48(4), 535-551.
- Almond, P. et Connolly, H. (2020). A manifesto for “slow” comparative research in work and employment, Euopean Journal of Industrial Relations, 26(1), 59-74.
- Alvesson, M. (1996). Developing programmatic research. In Frost, P.J. et Taylor, M.S. (eds.), Rhythms of academic life : Personal accounts of careers in academia. Thousand Oaks : SAGE Publications.
- Alvesson, M. et J, Sandberg (2013). Constructing research questions : doing interesting research, Los Angeles, Sage Publications.
- Alvesson, M., Bridgman, T., et H. Willmott, H. (eds.) (2009). Oxford Handbook of Critical Management Studies. Oxford, Oxford University Press
- Amdam, R. P. et Elias, A.L. (2021). Business schools and the roles of the executives’wives, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 20(3), 300-319.
- Amis, J.M., Munir, K. A., Lawrence, T. B., Hirsch, P. et McGahan, A. (2018). Inequality, institutions and organizations, Organization Studies, 39(9), 1131-1152.
- Anderson, L., P. Hibbert, K. Mason et C. Rivers (2018). Management education in turbulent times, Journal of Management Education, 42(4), 423-440.
- Antonacopoulou, E. (2010). Making the business school more critical : Reflexive critique based on phronesis as a foundation for impact, British Journal of Management, 21 (s1), 6-25.
- Augier M. et M. Prietula (2007). Historical Roots of the Cyert-March Computer Model at GSIA, Organization Science, 18(3), 507-522.
- Banerjee, S. B. et Prasad, A. (2008). Introduction to the special issue on “Critical reflections on management and organizations : A postcolonial perspective, Critical Perspectives on International Business, 4 (2/3), 90-98.
- Banerjee, S.B. et Arjaliès, D-L. 2021. Celebrating the end of enlightenment : Organization theory on the age of the Anthropocene and Gaia (and why neither is the solution to our ecological crisis), Organization Theory, 2, 1-24.
- Banerjee, S.B. et Berrier-Lucas, C (2022). Decolonizing The Business School : A Journey on paths less travelled with Bobby Banerjee, Revue de l’Organisation Responsible, 17(2), 36-41.
- Beaujolin-Bellet, R., Grima, F. (2011). Ces enseignants chercheurs qui introduisent la critique dans les écoles de commerce françaises. In Taskin, L. & de Nanteuil, M. (Eds.), Perspectives critiques en Management. Pour une gestion citoyenne. Bruxelles : De Boeck.
- Berger, M. et Seeber. B.K. (2016). The slow professor : Changing the culture of speed in the academy. Toronto : Toronto University Press.
- Berrier-Lucas, C., Ramboarisata, L. et Ramonjy, D. (2022). Decolonizing Teaching : Insights from Corporate Social Responsibility. Actes de la conférence Gender Work & Organization, Bogota.
- Bhabha, H. (1994). The Location of culture. Londres : Routeledge.
- Billsberry, J., Kohler, T., Stratton, M., Cohen M. et Taylor, S.M. (2019). From the Editors : Introduction to the special issues on rhythms of academic life, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 18(2), 119-127.
- Bogle, D. (2020), How will COVID-19 affect research collaboration ?, University World News.
- Bowes-Catton, J. B., Clarke, C., Drake, D. H., Gilmour, A. et Penn, A. (2021). Talkin ‘bout a revolution ? From quiescence to resistance in the contemporary university, Management Learning, 51(4), 378-397.
- Brammer, S. et Clark, T. (2020), COVID-19 and management education : Reflections of challenges, opportunities, and potential futures, British Journal of Management, 31, 453-456.
- Bristow, A. S. Robinson et O. Ratle (2017). Being an Early-Career CMS Academic in the Context of Insecurity and “Excellence” : The Dialectics of Resistance and Compliance, Organization Studies, 38(9), 1185-1207.
- Butler, N., Delaney, H. et M. Slywa (ed.) (2017). “The Labour of academia”, Ephemera : Theory and Politics in Organization, 17(3).
- Chamayou, G. (2009). “Petits conseils aux enseignants-chercheurs qui veulent réussir leur évaluation”, Revue du MAUSS, 33(1), 208-226.
- Clegg, S. et A. Ross-Smith (2003). Revising the boundaries : Management education and learning in a postpositivist world, Academy of Management Learning and Education, 2(1), 85-98.
- Contu, A. (2018). ‘… The point is to change it’ – Yes, but in what direction and how ? Intellectual activism as a way of “walking the talk” of critical work in business schools, Organization, 25(2), 282-293.
- Contu, A. (2020). Answering the crisis with intellectual activism : Making a difference as a business school scholars. Human Relations, 73(5), 737-757.
- Cooke, B. et R. Alcadipani (2015). Toward a Global History of Management Education : : The Case of the Ford Foundation and the São Paulo School of Business Administration, Brazil, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 14(4), 482-499.
- Cooke, B. (2003). The denial of slavery in management studies, Journal of Management Studies, 40(8), 1895-1918.
- Cunliffe, A. L. (2002). Reflexive dialogical practice in management learning, Management Learning, 33, 35-61.
- D’Cruz, P., Delannon, N., Kourula, A., McCarthy, L., Moon, J., et Spence, L.J. (2021). ‘Contesting social responsibilities of business : Experiences in context’ (special issue call for papers), Human Relations, 74(2), 319-325.
- Dar, Sadhvi, Liu, Helena, Dy, A.M. (2021). The business school is racist : Act up !, Organization, 28(4), 695-706.
- Dea, S. (2020), “Academic freedom in the time of coronavirus”, University Affairs.
- Dehler, G. E. (2009). Prospects and possibilities of critical management education : Critical beings and a pedagogy of critical action, Management Learning, 40, 31-49.
- Devinney, T., J.R. Dowling et M. Perm-Ajchariyawong (2008). The Financial Times business school ranking : What quality is this signal of quality ?, European Management Review, 5(4), 195-208.
- Doucette, M.B., Gladstone, J. S. et Carter, T. (2021). Indigenous Conversational Approach to History and Business Education, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 20(3), 473-484.
- Duberley, J. et P. Johnson (2009). Critical Management Methodology, dans Alvesson, M., Bridgman, T., et H. Willmott, H. (eds.), Oxford Handbook of Critical Management Studies. Oxford, Oxford University Press.
- Duncanson, K., Weir, N., Siriwardhane, P. and Khan, T. (2020), How Covid is widening the academic gender divide, The Conversation.
- Dunne, S., S. Harney, M. Parker et T. Tinker (2008). Discussing the role of the business school, Ephemera, 8(3), 271-293.
- Durepos, G. (2016). Early career reflections on discursive pressures in business schools. In Prasad, A. (ed.), Contesting institutional hegemony in today’s business schools. Doctoral students speak out, 17-30. Bingley : Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
- Dyer, S. L. et Hurd, F. (2016). What’s going on ?” Developing reflexivity in the management classroom : From surface to deep learning and everything in between, Academy of Management Learning & Education, vol. 15, 287-303.
- Elsbach, K.D. et R.M. Kramer (1996). Members’ responses to organizational identity threats : encountering and countering the Business Week rakings, Administrative Science Quarterly, 41(3), 442-476.
- Engwall L. (2008), The university : a multinational corporation ?, dans Engwall, L. et Weaire, D. (éds), The University in the Market, 9-21. London, Portland Press.
- Etzkowitz H. (2003). Research groups as ‘quasi-firms’ : the invention of the entrepreneurial university, Research Policy, 32(1), 109-121.
- Ferreras, I., Battilana, J. et Méda, D. 2020. Le manifeste travail. Démocratiser, démarchandiser, dépolluer. Paris : Seuil.
- Fleming, P. (2021). Dark academia. How universities die. Londres : Pluto Press.
- Fotaki, M. et Prasad, A. (2015). Questioning neoliberal capitalism and economic inequality in business schools, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 14(4), 556-575.
- Fourcade, M. et R. Khurana (2013). From social control to financial economics : the linked ecologies of economies and business in twentieth century America, Theory and Society, 42(2), 121-159.
- Freire, P., et Faundez, A. (1989). Learning to question : A pedagogy of liberation. WCC Publ.
- Gantman, E.R., Yousfi, H. et alcadipani, R. (2015). Challenging Anglo-Saxon dominance in management and organisational knowledge, Revista de Administracao de Empresas, 55(2), 126-129.
- Germain, O. & Taskin, L. (2017). Être formé pour et…par la recherche, Revue Internationale PME, 30(2), 7-16.
- Gioia D.A. et K.G. Corley (2002), Being good versus looking good : Business school rankings and the Circean transformation from substance to image, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 1(1), 107-120.
- Girei, E. (2017). Decolonising management knowledge : a reflexive journey as practitioner and researcher in Uganda. Management Learning, 48(4) 453-470.
- Grey, R. et Mitev, N. (1995). Management education : A polemic, Management Learning, 26 (1), 73-90.
- Gueyé, B., Ngaha Ba, A., Song-Naba, F., Dan Rani Guero, B. et Germain, O. (2022). Appel à contributions pour le numéro special “Nouveaux imaginaires de et sur l’Afrique par l’entrepreneuriat”, Revue international PME.
- Hall, S. (2008). Geographies of business education : MBA programs, reflexive business schools, and the cultural circuit of capital, Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 33(1), 27-41.
- Hall, S. et L. Appleyard (2009). The city of London, city of learning ? Placing business education within the geographies of finance, Journal of Economic Geography, 9(5), 597-617.
- Hearn, J.C. et Burns, R. (2021). Contingent faculty employment and financial stress in public universities, The Journal of Higher Education, 92(3), 331-362.
- https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---ed_dialogue/---sector/documents/meetingdocument/wcms_837723.pdf
- Huault, I. et Perret, V. (2011). L’enseignement critique du management comme espace d’émancipation : une réflexion autour de la pensée de Jacques Rancière. M@n@gement, 14, 282-309.
- Jammulamadaka, N., Faria, A., Jack, G. et Ruggunan, S. (2021). Decolonising management and organizational knowledge (MOK) : Praxistical theorizing for potential worlds. Organization, 28(5), 717-740.
- Jones, D.R., Visser, M., Stokes, P., Örtenblad, A., Deem, R., Rodgers, P. et Y Tarba, S. (2020). The performative university : ’Targets’, ‘Terror’ and ‘Taking back freedom’ in academia, Management Learning, 51(4), 1-15.
- Kavanagh, D. (2022) Don’t shut down the business schools, re-locate them”, Introduction to Special Issue, Ephemera, forthcoming.
- Kettunen K., Juusola K., Alajoutsiravi K. (2015). What happens to the Professor ? Business schools, corporatization, and eroding professionalism, in Bowden B., Lamond D. (eds.), Management History : Its Global Past & Present (Management History : Global Perspectives), 133-156. Charlotte, Information Age Publishing.
- Khurana R. (2007). From Higher Aims to Hired Hands : The Social Transformation of American Business Schools and the Unfulfilled Promise of Management as a Profession. Princeton University Press, Princeton.
- Khurana R. et J.C. Spender (2012). Herbert A. Simon on What Ails Business Schools : More than “A problem in Organizational Design”, Journal of Management Studies, 49(3), 619-639.
- Khurana, R., S.A. Snook (2011). Identity Work in Business Schools : From Don Quixote, to Dons and Divas, Journal of Management Inquiry, 20(4), 358-361.
- Kipping, M., B. Usdiken et N. Puig (2004). Imitation, Tension, and Hybridization : Multiple “Americanizations” of Management Education in Mediterranean Europe, Journal of Management Inquiry, 13(2), 98-108.
- Lagasnerie (de), G. (2011), Logique de la création. Sur l’Université, la vie intellectuelle et les conditions de l’innovation, Fayard, coll. « à venir ».
- Laszlo, C., R. Sroufe et S. Waddock (2017). Torn between two paradigms : A struggle for the soul of business schools, AI Practitioner, 19(2), 108-119.
- Lezaun, J. et F. Muniesa (2017). Twilight in the leadership playground : subrealism and the training of the business self, Journal of Cultural Economy, 10(3), 265-279.
- Liu, H. et Baker, C. (2016). White knights : Leadership and the heroicisation of whiteness. Leadership, 12(4), 420-448.
- Liu, H. et Pechenkina, E. (2016). Staying quiet or rocking the boat ? An autoethnography of organisational visual white supremacy, Equality, Diversity and Inclusion : An International Journal, 35(3), 186-204.
- Lussault, M. (2013). L’avènement du monde. Essai sur l’habitation humaine de la terre. Paris : Seuil.
- Marinetto, M. (2018). Fast food research in the era of planned obsolescence, Journal of Management Studies, 55(6), 1014-1020.
- Mautner G. (2005). The entrepreneurial university. A discursive profile of a higher education buzzword, Critical Discourse Studies, 2(2), 95-120.
- McLaren, P. G., Bridgmann, T., Cummings, S., Lubinski, C., O’Connor, E., Spender, J.-C. et Durepos, G. (2021). From the editors : New times, new histories of the business school, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 20(3), 293-299.
- Mir, R. et Mir, A. (2013). The colony writes back : Organization as an early champion of non-Western organizational theory. Organization, 20(1), 91-101.
- Mutch, A. (2021). Business Education in the U.K. Polytechnic Tradition : Uncovering Alternative Approaches through Historical Investigation, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 20(3), 407-422.
- Nkomo, S. (1992). The emperor has no clothes : rewriting “race in organizations”. Academy of Management Review, 17(3), 487-513.
- Nkomo, S. (2011). A postcolonial and anti-colonial reading of “African” leadership and management in organization studies : tensions, contradictions and possibilities, Organization, 18(3), 365-386.
- Nkomo, S. M. (1988). Race and Sex : The Forgotten Case of the Black Female Manager. In Rose, S. et Larwood, L. (eds) Women’s Careers : Pathways and Pitfalls, 133-150. New York : Praeger.
- Noguéira, J.M.M., Coelho, C. et Aguiar, A.C. (2021). Enlightenment, critical theory, and the role of the business schools in the anthropocene. Revista de Gestao Social e Ambiental, 15, 1-15.
- Ortiz, H. et F. Muniesa (2018). Business schools, the anxiety of finance, and the order of the “middle teer”, Journal of Cultural Economy, 11(1), 1-19.
- Palpacuer, F. & Smith, A. (2021). Rethinking Value Chains : tacking the challenges of global capitalism, coord., Bristol Policy Press, Open Access.
- Parker, M. (2018). Shut down the business school. What’s wrong with management education. Londres : Pluto Press.
- Pechenkina, E. et Liu, H. (2018). Instruments of white supremacy : People of colour resisting white domination in higher education, Whiteness and Education, vol. 3, no. 1, pp. 1-14.
- Perret, V. et Taskin, L. (2019). Les temporalités de la recherche critique en management. Enjeux et alternatives. Laval : Presses de l’Université Laval.
- Perriton, l. et Reynolds, M. (2004). Critical management education : From pedagogy of possibility to pedagogy of refusal ?. Management Learning, 35(1), 61-77.
- Petriglieri, G. et J.L. Petriglieri (2010). Identity workspaces : The case of business schools, Academy of Management Learning and Education, 9(1), 44-60.
- Prasad, A. (2016). Contesting institutional hegemony in today’s business schools. Doctoral students speak out. Bingley : Emerald Group Publishing Limited.
- Prasad, A. et Caproni, P.J. (1997). Critical theory in the management classroom : Engaging power, ideology, and praxis, Journal of Management Education, 21(3), 284-291.
- Prieto, L., Philips, S., Giugni, L. et Stott, N. (2021). Teaching (Cooperative) Business : The “Bluefield Experiment” and the Future of Black Business Schools, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 20(3), 320-341.
- Raineri, N. (2013). The PhD program : Between conformity and reflexivity, Journal of Organizational Ethnography, 2(1), 37-56.
- Raineri, N. (2015). Business doctoral education as a liminal period of transition : Comparing theory and practice, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 26, 99-107.
- Ramboarisata, L. (2022). Post-pandemic responsible management education : An invitation for a conceptual and practice renewal and for a narrative change, Journal of Global Responsibility, 13(1), 29-41.
- Ramboarisata, L. et Gendron, C. (2019). Beyond moral righteousness : the challenges of non- utilitarian ethics, CSR, and sustainability education, The International Journal of Management Education, 17(3), 1-12.
- Ramboarisata, L., Berrier-Lucas, C., Aissi Befekih, L., Benouakrim, H., Ramonjy, D. et Tello Rozas, S. (ed.) (2022). Décoloniser la RSE : perspectives critiques, Revue de l’organisation responsable. 17(2).
- Ratle, O., Robinson, S et Bristow, A. (2020). Mechanism of micro-terror ? Early career CMS academics’ experiences of “tagets and terror” in contemporary business school, Management Learning, 51(4), 452-471.
- Rosenthal, C. (2021). Reckoning with slavery : How revisting management’s uncomfortable part can help us confront challenges today, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 20(3), 467-472.
- Ross, E. W. (2020). “The labour of COVID ”, call for papers for Workplace : A Journal for Academic Labour.
- Ross, J. et McKie, A. (2020). Will Covid kill off the teaching-research employment model ?, Times Higher Education.
- Rottner, R. M. (2021). Feeling Left Out : Revising Business School History and Inserting Lyrical Sociology, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 20(3), 423-441.
- Rowlinson, M. et J. Hassard (2011). How come the critters come to be teaching in business schools ?, Organization, 18(5), 673-689.
- Siltaoja, M., K. Juusola et M. Kivijarvi (2019). “World-class” fantasies : A neo-colonial analysis of international branch campuses, Organization. 26(1), 75-97.
- Slaughter, S.; Leslie, Larry L. (1997). Academic Capitalism : Politics, Policies, and the Entrepreneurial University. The Johns Hopkins University Press.
- Smouts, M-C. (2007). La situation postcoloniale, les postcolonial studies dans le débat français. Paris : Les presses Sciences po.
- Spicer, A., Jaser, Z. et Wiertz, C. (2021). The Future of the Business School : Finding Hope in Alternative Pasts, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 20(3), 459-456.
- Stewart, P. et Lucio, M. (2017). Research, participation and the neo-liberal context : The challenges of emergent participatory and emancipatory research approaches, Ephemera, 17(3), 533-556.
- Steyaert, C., Beyes, T. et M. Parker (eds) (2016). The Routledge Companion to Reinventing Management Education, Abingdon, Oxon : Routledge.
- Sutherland, I., J.R. Gosling et J. Jelinek (2015). Aesthetics of power : Why teaching about power is easier than learning for power, and what business schools could do about it, Academy of Management Learning and Education, 14(4), 607-624.
- Taskin L., Willmott H. (2008). Introducing critical management studies : Key dimensions, Gestion 2000, 25(10), 27-38.
- Taskin, L. et M. de Nanteuil (eds.) (2011). Perspectives critiques en management, De Boeck.
- Tim-adical Writing Collective (2017). Vulnerabilities, complicities, and injustices : “Tim-adical” actions for change in the noliberal academy, Ephemera, 17(3), 691-704.
- Tsing, A. (2005) Frictions. An ethnography of global connection. Princeton University Press.
- Tsing, Anna (2005) Frictions. An ethnography of global connection. Princeton University Press.
- Turner, V. (1987). Betwixt and between : A liminal period in rites of passage. In Mahdi, L.C., Foster, S. et Little, L. (eds.), Betwixt and between : Patterns of masculine and feminine initiation, 3-19. Peru, IL : Open court Publishing.
- UNESCO et BIT (2021). Rapport du comité conjoint sur l’application des recommandations concernant le personnel enseignant.
- Üsdiken, B., Kipping, M. et Engwall, L. (2021). Professional School Obsession : An Enduring Yet Shifting Rhetoric by U.S. Business Schools, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 20(3), 442-458.
- Wadhwani, R. D. et Viebig, C. (2021). Social Imaginaries of Entrepreneurship Education : The United States and Germany, 1800-2020, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 20(3), 342-360.
- Wanderley, S., Alcadipani, R., Barros, A. (2021). Recentering the Global South in the making of the business schools histories : Dependency ambiguity in action, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 20(3), 361-381.
- Wedlin, L. (2006). Ranking Business Schools : Forming fields, identities, and boundaries in international management education. Cheltenham : Edward Elgar.
- Wedlin, L. (2007). The role of rankings in codifying a business school template : classification, diffusion and mediated isomorphism in organizational fields, European Management Review, 4(1), 24-39.
- Wedlin, L. (2011). Going global : Rankings as rhetorical devices to construct an international field of Management education, Management Learning, 42(2), 199-218.
- Wieners, S., Weber, S. M. (2020). Athena’s claim in an academic regime of performativity : Discursive organizing of excellence and gender at the intersection of heterotopia and heteronomia. Management Learning, 51(4), 511-530.
- Wright, C., Nyberg, D., Rickards, L. et Freund, J. (2018). Organizing in the anthopocene, Organization, 25(4), 455-471.
- Young, K. (2020), “Pandemic exacerbates already high level of stress among women faculty”, Ms. Magazine.
- Yousfi, H. (2021). Decolonizing Arab organizational knowledge : “Fahlawa” as a research practice, Organization, 28(5), 836-856.
- Zawadzki, M. et Jensen, T (2020). Bullying and the neoliberal university : A co-authored autoethnography. Management Learning, 51(4), 398-413.
- Zoogah, B. D. (2021). Historicizing management and organization in Africa, Academy of Management Learning & Education, 20(3), 382-406.
- Zulfiqar, G. et Prasad, A. (2021). How is social inequality maintained in the Global South ? Critiquing the concept of dirty work, Human Relations, online first.